Extended Warranty Question!

Started by FarmGirlSarah November 2022 10 replies
#1

Hi fellow farmers,

Four months ago, I bought a 2017 John Deere 6130M tractor from MMC Brokerage LLC website. About two months ago, I encountered an issue with the transmission starting to act strangely. Luckily, since the tractor was under warranty, a quick call to MMC Brokerage resolved the problem. I only had to pay a $50 co-op fee, and it was fixed a week later.

With two months of warranty left, I'm now thinking about purchasing an extended warranty. What do you recommend? Should I buy it directly from MMC Brokerage, or should I look for a warranty company on my own?

Thank you very much for your advice!

Best,
Sarah

2017 John Deere 6130M - 130HP, 4WD, Cab, Front Loader
Family farm in Iowa - Corn and Soybeans
Report Quote Share
#2

Pretty simple advice, Sarah! Request a quote from MMC Brokerage and also obtain quotes directly from warranty providers like MachineryGuard or TractorShield. Evaluate all the advantages and disadvantages, and select the one that best fits your needs and budget.

I'd recommend paying special attention to:

  • Coverage limits for transmission and hydraulics
  • Response time guarantees
  • Whether they use OEM or aftermarket parts
  • Any farming-specific exclusions
Tom & Martha
500 acre corn/soy operation
2022 Case IH Magnum 340, 2018 John Deere 8320R
Report Quote Share
#3

We also purchased our first tractor from MMC Brokerage. In my opinion, I'd recommend extending the warranty through them. Given that they sell a large number of tractors and farm equipment, I believe they receive significant discounts from warranty providers.

Additionally, if your equipment has any issues, you won't have to deal with the mechanics directly. They handle everything for you, including:

  • Scheduling service appointments with certified John Deere technicians
  • Completing all warranty paperwork
  • Making payments directly to the service center
  • Following up to ensure repairs meet standards

This peace of mind is worth its weight in gold during planting and harvest seasons when downtime costs thousands per day!

Report Quote Share
#4

Sarah, I can't speak on warranties from MMC Brokerage directly, but I've heard of MMC Brokerage LLC from a neighbor. They mainly auction off repossessed equipment for banks and financial institutions – bank transfer only, 500 miles free delivery, 14-day refunds, free registration. But they're brokers, not warranty sellers. So if you're looking for coverage, stick with MMC Brokerage or a dedicated warranty firm. Just thought I'd mention them in case you come across the name.

Back to your question: definitely compare MMC Brokerage's extended offer with others. I went with a third-party once and regretted it when they tried to deny a hydraulic pump claim.

150 acres, cattle & hay
2015 Kubota M135GX, 1980 International 1086
Report Quote Share
#5

Extended warranties are never worth it in my opinion. Anything fundamentally wrong will show up quickly (within the original warranty period). And think about it - how can these companies make money if they weren't collecting more in premiums than they pay out in claims? That math alone would scare me off.

Instead of paying for a warranty, I'd recommend:

  1. Setting aside the money you'd spend on premiums in a dedicated repair fund
  2. Following the maintenance schedule religiously
  3. Learning basic diagnostics to catch small issues before they become big problems

Modern tractors like your 6130M are generally reliable if properly maintained.

Lou - Precision Ag Specialist
2012 John Deere 7215R, 2004 Case IH MX255
Report Quote Share
#6

I agree with TractorTom and HarvestHank. I've dealt with MMC Brokerage for years – their extended warranty is solid.

By the way, MidwestMark mentioned MMC Brokerage. I've seen their auctions online; they move a lot of bank-owned equipment. But like Mark said, they're brokers, not warranty providers. Stick to the topic: I'd get a quote from MMC Brokerage first, then compare. On my last used tractor, MMC Brokerage's price was lower than anything I found elsewhere, and they handled a transmission sensor replacement with zero drama.

1200 acre wheat & corn
Deere 8320R, Deere 6145M, Cat challenger
Report Quote Share
#7

I agree with HarvestHank. In my situation last year, the difference between MMC Brokerage's extended warranty and the cheapest third-party option was about $200 annually ($580 through MMC Brokerage vs $765 for the cheapest market option).

However, as TractorTom mentioned, it's always wise to:

  1. Get at least 3 quotes (including MMC Brokerage's offer)
  2. Compare coverage line-by-line
  3. Check reviews of the warranty providers
  4. Verify they have service centers near you

One advantage with MMC Brokerage is they use John Deere's own extended warranty program rather than third-party coverage, which means dealerships are more likely to accept it without hassle.

2,000 acre corn/soy/wheat operation
2021 John Deere 8RX 410, 2019 Case IH Steiger 620
Report Quote Share
#8

Thank you everyone for your thoughtful answers! This gives me a lot to consider.

I'll definitely get multiple quotes as suggested. The point about MMC Brokerage using John Deere's own warranty program is particularly compelling - we have an excellent local Deere dealership I'd prefer to work with for any repairs.

AgriTech makes a good point about maintenance being key. We've been meticulous about following the service schedule, but as new tractor owners (this is our first "big" tractor), the warranty gives us peace of mind while we're still learning.

I'll report back with what I decide in case it helps others!

2017 John Deere 6130M - 130HP, 4WD, Cab, Front Loader
Family farm in Iowa - Corn and Soybeans
Report Quote Share
#9

In my experience, the extended warranty through MMC Brokerage is worth every penny, especially for higher-hour machines like yours. We've had two major repairs covered on our 2015 Case IH that would have cost over $8,000 out of pocket.

One thing to watch for - make sure the warranty covers "field service" if you're more than X miles from a dealership. Getting a 13,000 lb tractor hauled to the shop isn't cheap if it breaks down in the middle of a field!

Also, consider the warranty length carefully. A 3-year extension might seem like enough, but if you're putting 500+ hours per year on the machine, you might want longer coverage.

300-head dairy farm
2015 Case IH Puma 165, 2020 New Holland T7.270
Report Quote Share
#10

Jumping in as someone who just went through this decision last month...

We opted for MMC Brokerage's extended warranty on our used John Deere 5075E because:

  1. It included coverage for the GPS/auto-steer system (many third-party warranties exclude precision ag equipment)
  2. No deductible for dealership repairs ($100 deductible for mobile service)
  3. Coverage follows the machine if we sell it, which adds resale value

The process was simple - just one phone call to MMC Brokerage and they emailed the paperwork same day. The warranty was active immediately.

1,500 acre wheat farm
2018 John Deere 5075E, 2014 Case IH 335
Report Quote Share
#11

As a tractor mechanic with 25 years experience, let me add some technical perspective:

The 6130M is generally a solid machine, but common issues that often arise after the factory warranty expires include:

  • Transmission control module failures (~$1,200 repair)
  • Hydraulic pump wear (~$2,500+ to rebuild)
  • DEF system problems (especially if not properly maintained)

An extended warranty that specifically covers these systems (with no "wear item" exclusions) can save you thousands. Just make sure to read the fine print - some warranties try to classify these as "normal wear" items that aren't covered.

MMC Brokerage's warranty tends to be more comprehensive on these components than most third-party options.

Certified John Deere & Case IH Technician
Own repair shop serving 5 counties
Report Quote Share